Moana's live-action remake has underperformed at the box office, marking a significant setback for Disney's live-action remake strategy. The film's $43 million opening weekend in North America, despite a $250 million production budget, is a stark contrast to Disney's previous successes with live-action remakes. This underperformance raises questions about the timing and cultural resonance of Disney's live-action remakes, particularly when they are released too soon after the original animated versions. The film's weak performance overseas, with $52 million in global sales, further underscores the challenges it faces. The article delves into the reasons behind Moana's underperformance, including the proximity to the animated sequel and the lack of cultural resonance. It also compares the film's performance to other Disney live-action remakes and explores the broader implications for the studio's future projects. The analysis concludes by reflecting on the lessons learned from Moana's underperformance and speculating on the potential future of Disney's live-action remake strategy.